From L'Express
June, 25 1998.
Original in French.
(p 48 ff)
Based on Enquête sur la mort de Diana,
By Jean-Marie Pontaut and Jérome Dupuis
Copyright
Translated By Alan Hope
Stéphane Darmon, partner of Romuald Rat, arrives at scene of
crash on
motorcycle (mounted two-up with Rat):
“I saw the car [the Mercedes] in the tunnel, jammed up against the
right-hand wall. I took a rapid decision to overtake. I drove over
glass
shards, and stopped 10 metres further on. Romuald got off immediately
and
went in the direction of the car.”
Romuald Rat, photographer:
“Whe I got off the bike I left my helmet down. I told Stéphane
to go on a
bit with the bike, and I ran towards the car. At that point I saw it
was a
Mercedes, and realised it could have been the couple. I became certain
once
I had reached the car and I recognised Mr al-Fayed. At that point I
was
shocked, because it wasn't a pretty sight. I drew back for a few seconds.
While running towards the car, I had taken two pictures. I took another
as
I drew back, after seeing al-Fayed in the car. All of this took less
than
ten seconds.”
Two more photographers (Serge Arnal and Christian Martinez) arrive at
the
scene in a black Fiat:
Martinez:
“We came by the car very quickly, at about 90-100 kph. We stopped about
20
metres further on. I don't remember if there were other vehicles there
at
the time. Some vehicles had already stopped on the other side of the
road,
but not on our side. I took out my camera. We went towards the crash
scene
and that's where I remember seeing Rat. He seemed shocked by what had
happened, and was wandering aimlessly.”
Serge Arnal:
“Once I got out of the car, I didn't get too close, as I hate the sight
of
blood. I saw the state of the car, and realised it was very serious.
I used
my mobile phone to call the emergency services. It was my first reflex.
I
had to move away from the site of the accident to get a better line.
I went
towards the exit of the tunnel in the direction of Trocadéro.
I screamed
into my mobile phone because the sound was bad. I was in a panic.”
[AH note - Arnal is reported to have dialed 12 instead of the correct
number, 112]
L'Express: At the same moment, at 0026, that is one minute after the
accident, a woman driving on the opposite carriageway calls the fire
brigade on her mobile phone. Three minutes later, the police emergency
number receives a call from a phone box in Place de l'Alma.
A pedestrian, Belkacem B., arrives on foot:
“I rushed over to the damaged vehicle, and immediately saaw the driver
had
been squashed to a pulp, with his hand through the windscreen. I saw
the
passenger had his jaw cut and dropping down, his body held upright
by his
seat-belt and leaning against the Airbag. He was trapped in the vehicle
and
there was no way to open the door. I thought it better not to touch
him. In
the back seat was a man of about forty, stretched out, his feet in
an
awkward position, his eyes turned back in his head. I saw right away
he was
dead. Beside him, between the right-hand front seat and the back seat,
a
blonde woman was doubled up on herself with a gash on her forehead
and her
watch-strap undone. She moaned, and said a few words in English. "My
God,
My God," I think. She still had her shoes on her feet. I tried to open
the
door on the woman's side, but could not. I was the first to try to
open one
of the car doors, as it happens the one which seemed the easiest but
which,
all the same, resisted. As I arrived in the tunnel, I also saw the
flash of
cameras coming from behind the car. I was surprised at these flashes,
although also pleased, as I thought it meant the emergency services
were
already there. However, coming closer to the car, I saw there were
four
photographers. As I tried to open one of the car doors, I asked the
photographers and especially the biggest of them (Romuald Rat) what
we had
to do. The fat photogrpaher who was taking pictures of the car said
to me:
'Don't touch anything. It's Princess Diana. She's with Dodi!' I asked
him
again: 'What should I do? What should I do?' He told me to keep back
other
vehicles.”
Romuald Rat decides to try and open the right-hand back door of the
Mercedes:
“I wanted to help them, because I have qualifications in first aid and
resuscitation. I thought the driver and bodyguard were dead. I saw
Dodi
al-Fayed bent over in the back seat, lying facing me, his eyes half-open.
There was nothing more to be done for him. The Princess was on the
floor,
between the two seats, her back to me, with a floor-mat covering her.
I
lifted it [the mat] to see if she was still alive, and placed the mat
on
the groin/lower stomach of al-Fayed. I wanted to take Diana's pulse.
When I
touched her, she began to moan. Her head was bent slightly back, and
she
seemed to be breathing. I said to her in English: "Be cool, doctor
is
arriving' [sic] Just at that moment the bodyguard began to move around
violently in his seat. He was nudging the Princess at the same time.
I got
up and went to look at him. His face was terribly damaged on the left
side.
I touched him gently on the cheek and the head to let him know I was
there.
I told him the same thing I had told the Princess. I went round to
the
front of the car, and saw that the driver was completely hemmed in.
I
wanted to see if I could disconnect the battery, but with the state
the
car was in, it wasn't even worth thinking about. I went back to the
rear of
the car, where the Princess was. I remember somebody showed up carrying
a
small white oxygen mask.”
Rat takes several photos of the scene. Martinez admits to having done
the
same thing in the heat of the moment.
Martinez:
"I tried to get Diana: I think I had to zoom in to get her. I was maybe
1.50 to 2 metres away from her, not doing anything."
Martinez and Rat exchange insults. Rat tells Martinez to get back, and
take
no pictures of the interior of the car. Martinex tells Rat to "fuck
off".
Martinez:
“We were all distressed at one moment or another.We left, we came back:
our
only reaction was the desire to remain close to the scene. The only
one who
moved in on the car was Rat. I think he's a good guy: he did his job
without malice, just like us. You have to remember we do a good-natured
job. We take pictures of movie stars, of singers [à deux francs
cinquante -
no translation] ... it's true we didn't help the wounded. Maybe out
of
modesty. It's a signof great arrogance to go to the aid of people we
were
following a few minutes beforehand. I was paralysed by the relationship
between me and the people in that car.”
Dr Frédéric Mailliez arrives on the scene in his SOS-Médecins
car. He takes
in the scene, pinpoints the location on a map and calls for help by
radio.
He asks for two ambulances and a rescue vehicle for the trapped victims.
He
take an oxygen mask from his car and goes back to the Mercedes, where
he
gives first aid to Diana, helping her breath and ensuring her airway
is not
blocked by bleeding. The Princess, unconscious, lets out a moan. As
she has
no external injuries apart from a small scratch on her forehead the
doctor
considers she has a good chance of survival. In the meantime, a volunteer
fireman who was passing, gives first aid to Trevor Rees-Jones.
Traffic arriving in the tunnel in both directions has caused snarl-ups.
Some people get out of their cars, others try to go through.
A witness:
“I thought it was a terrorist attack or the set of a film. My friend
stopped
me getting out of the car, fearing an explosion.”
A man of "Egyptian type" dressed in a striped suit, according to witnesses,
asks drivers to reverse away from the scene. Another passer-by sees
a
police patrol car on the cours Albert 1er. The two occupants, from
the
VIIIe arrondissement station, are alerted and park at the entrance
to the
tunnel. Passersby inform them "Lady Di" [sic} is in the car, and they
approach.
Sébastien Dorzee, one of the two officers [the other is Lino Gaggliardone]:
“There was group of 10 to 15 photographers taking pictures. The flashes
were
going off like machine guns, and each of them must have shot off a
whole
film. I immediately got out of the car and ran to the scene. As soon
as I
saw the accident and the presence of the photographers I thought it
must be
someone important. I saw the driver of the Mercedes who was obviously
dead.
The front-seat passenger's face was very bloody. He was looking at
me. He
was incapable of speaking, as his jaw was split in two. I realised
the
photographers were not taking pictures of either the driver or the
front-seat passenger, but of the rear of the car, while the right-hand
rear
door was partly open. I had to open the door a bit more to gain access,
and
immediately recognised Princess Diana. I tried to push back the
photographers, who were enraged. In the struggle, I was pushed several
times. At no time did a photographer come to lend a hand. They just
went on
taking pictures. It was clear I was getting in their way. When I opened
the
back door further, I saw the passenger on the left of the back seat
was
dead.”
Dorzee goes on:
“The Princess had made a half-turn from her initial [seated] position,
and
her head was between the two front seats, facing sideways. She could
see
her companion in front of her. She moved, with her eyes open, and spoke
to
me in a foreign language [English]. I think she said 'My God' as she
saw
her friend was dead. At the same time, she stroked her stomach. She
must
have been in pain. I tried to lean into the car, with my feet still
on the
ground outside, to try and prevent the photographers from taking more
pictures. She turned her head towards the front and saw the driver,
and
took in more of what had happened, I think. She started to get upset.
A few
seconds later, she looked at me. Then she laid down her head and closed
her
eyes. I noticed that there were jewels scattered on the floor [of the
car].
I took care that no-one pick them up.”
[snip witness reactions to photographers' conduct]
Rat's bike driver, Stéphane Darmon, on his colleagues' behaviour:
“I sat down for a moment on the edge of the passageway at the exit to
the
tunnel. Two women who live in the area came up to join me. They saw
I was
in a state of shock and comforted me a little. I had a bitter taste
in my
mouth with regard to the photographers, because I couldn't stand it
that
they were taking pictures.”
[...]
Emergency vehicles arrive at the crash scene: two vehicles from the
fire
brigade - an ambulance and a wreckage-rescue vehicle. A Samu ambulance.
On
board the Samu ambulance, whose arrival is logged at 0032 hrs, Dr Armold
Derossi. Dr Claude Fuilla attends for the fire brigade. Reinforcements
arrive shortly after - fire trucks from two stations, and two more
ambulances from the Necker hospital.
Jean-Marc Martino, anaesthetist and resuscitation surgeon of the Samu:
“I went off with the resuscitation ambulance and its usual crew: a paramedic
driver and an intern who is a medical student in training. We went
under
the Alma tunnel, where we arrived a few moments later at the scene.
On my
arrival, I was appraised of the identity of the victims as I made my
way
towards a crashed vehicle being worked on by firemen. I immediately
noted
the death of a man lying on the roadway - whom I later learned to be
Mr
al-Fayed - and of the driver. I saw by his [the driver's] side a trapped
man who was showing signs of life. I also saw, trapped on the floor
in the
back of the car, a woman I recognised as Lady Di [sic]. She was agitated
and crying out, and did not appear to understand what I was saying
to
reassure her. I asked my crew to take care of the front-seat passenger,
who
seemed the more seriously injured of the two [survivors], while calling
for
back-up from the Samu to allow me to take charge of the second victim.
I
did this having taken stock of the situation on the ground according
to the
usual procedure.”
Dr Martino continues:
“At that time a fire brigade doctor arrived with his crew, and took
charge
of the front-seat passenger, allowing me to concentrate on the Princess.
She was still agitated, mooving her left arm and right leg, and speaking
incoherently and in a confused way. Her right arm was bent behind her
-
dislocated. With my team I examined her and put her on a drip to allow
us
to release her from the wreck and take her to a hospital. She was locked
in
a "medically abnormal" [sic] position between the back of the front
passenger seat and the rear seat. We extracted her with difficulty
and
taking all the necessary precautions, with the aid of the firemen.
Despite
this, as this was being done, she suffered a cardiac arrest and I had
to
intubate her, ventilate her and use CPR to revive her. I got her into
my
ambulance to carry out a more thorough examination, and to continue
her
reanimation. She was in a serious condition.”
Ambulance attendant Michel Massebeuf:
“On our arrival the Samu doctor immediately started treating the Princess,
while she was in the car. According to what I saw, that's when she
was put
on a drip. The firemen extracted the Princess from the crash vehicle.
I
brought up the trolley, and she was put on. It seems to me she was
intubated at that point, to help her breathe. It migth have been in
our
vehicle that it happened. I don;t remember very well. We got the Princess
into our vehicle as is customary, so that the Samu doctor could take
care
of her in the best conditions.”
While this is going on, the fire brigade remove the roof of the Mercedes.
Trevor Rees-Jones is treated by Dr Le Hote from the Champerret fire
brigade
barracks.
Text: It is just before 1.30 [am]. It has taken nearly a hour for the
Samu
and the doctors to extract the Princess from the wreckage, establish
artificial respiration and give emergency treatment for a cardiac arrest.
Meantime, the emergency services look for the hospital best suited
to
receive her. Their choice lands on the large hospital of la
Pitié-Salpêtrière, just minutes from the Gare d'Austerlitz
- and more
especially the revival room of the department of anaesthetics and
resuscitation, which has already been alerted.
Prefect of police Philippe Massoni contacts Interior Minister Jean-Pierre
Chevènement, in residence at his second home in the Paris suburbs.
The
minister wants to come to the scene as quickly as possible, but the
prefect
advises him to go instead to the hospital. Massoni also contacts Christine
Albanel, cultural adviser to French president Jacques Chirac, on duty
at
the Elysée Palace. She decides to follow events rather than
wake the
president immediately. Prime minister Lionel Jospin is also alerted
in La
Rochelle. He makes an immediate flight to Paris on board an official
plane.
Christine Albanel calls British Ambassador Sir Michael Jay, who calls
the
Queen's private secretary at Balmoral, then goes to the hospital. Prince
Charles is contacted. He informs the Queen but leaves his two sons
to sleep
on.
Text: Mohammed al-Fayed, the father of Dodi, is informed by his men
in a
roundabout way. At about 0040, when they fail to see the Mercedes
containing Diana and Dodi arrive at the apartment in the rue
Arséne-Houssaye, bodyguard Kes Wingfield and driver Philippe
Dourneau start
to worry. Of course, it is possible Dodi changed the programme
unexpectedly. Wingfield tries to beep his colleague Trevor [Rees-Jones].
In
vain. In front of the entrance [to the apartment] two paparazzi, Stéphane
Cardinale and Pierre Suu are also waiting. Suddenly, Dourneau reports:
"One
of them gets a call on his mobile phone. He goes white. We grasp that
he
has received some terrible news. We had to insist before he would tell
us
that Dodi had just had an accident under the pont de l'Alma.”
... [The] Decision to transfer Diana to hospital taken about 0130. A
helicopter
evacuation is ruled out. Aside from the difficulty of bringing a helicopter
down on the expressway, the buffeting she might receive could be fatal
to
Diana, whose life "hangs by a thread". She is taken in the Samu Necker
ambulance, with two police cars as escort and motorcycle outriders.
At just before 0200, Chevénement joins Massoni at la Pitié-Salpêtrière,
at
the wing containing the intensive care unit. To their "great surprise"
the
ambulance containing the Princess has not yet arrived. The banks of
the
Seine have been closed to traffic, and even travelling at a cautious
40-50
kph to avoid aggravating the Princess's injuries, the ambulance should
already be there. Fearing an incident, perhaps involving journalists,
has
taken place, Massoni Calls Marcel Vinzerich, public security commissioner
on duty, who is directing the convoy from one of the two cars. He is
told
the ambulance has stopped on the pont d'Austerlitz: the doctors have
had to
undertake an emergency operation.
Michel Massebeuf:
“At the Jardin des Plantes, the doctor asked me to stop. We stopped
for
about five minutes so he could carry out a treatment which required
absolute immobility.”
Dr Martino:
“We stopped at the end of the pont d'Austerlitz. The patient was suffering
a
fall in blood pressure. Then we left again for the hospital, where
we
delivered the Princess to the duty resuscitation team, under the charge
of
Professor [Bruno] Riou, to whom I explained the situation. The victim
had
weak BP and had been intibated and ventilated.”
Daniel Eyraud, vascular surgeon:
“On her arrival, the Princess was unconscious and was being assisted
in her
breathing. She was in shock but had a cardiac rhythm. That means her
arterial BP was very low, but that her heart was still beating.”
X-rays show serious haemothorax [bleeding in chest cavity] compromising
her
heart and right lung. Requires drainage and massive transfusion. Cardiac
arrest between 0210 and 0215. Prof. Riou takes charge, and calls for
assistance from Prof. Alain Pavie, cardiac surgery specialist. But
without
waiting for Pavie, Riou decides to go ahead with surgery with the aid
of
Moncel Dahman, general surgeon. Thorax opened on right side.
Daniel Eyraud:
“I remember that the Princess's heart stopped just before this operation.”
Prof. Pavie arrives and takes over:
“On my arrival I had contact with Prof Riou and Dr Dahman. The discussion
lasted several seconds, given the gravity of the situation. They told
me Dr
Dahman had been forced to perform a thoracotomy [opening of chest cavity]
with external cardiac massage. The conversation was taking place as
he
carried out the necessary work on the patient, and I immediately agreed
to
Dr Dahman's assessment. The Princess's vital functions were being
maintained by Dr Dahman. I noted that the origin of the bleeding was
in the
perdicardial space, to the left and to the rear.”
[Signifies, says magazine, tearing of pulmonary vein. A nurse injects
repeated doses of adrenaline to keep heart going through repeated arrests.]
Dominique Hagnére, the nurse in question:
“Without this support for the circulatory function, she would have died
right away. Afterwards we realised we had injected her with about 150
ampoules of 5 ml/5 mg, which is an enormous amount. Later, the Princess's
condition made necessary a more serious surgical intervention.”
Prof Pavie:
“The treatment necessitated an enlargement of the surgical incision.
The
transfer to the operating wing of casualty [emergency room] was immediately
carried out, while internal cardiac massage was going on. Bleeding
was due
to a partial rupture of the left superior part of the [pulmonary] vein
where it joins the left auricle. This wound was sutured. Bleeding was
controlled and we continued with resuscitation.”
Daniel Hagnère:
“The patient remained dependent on cardiac massage and did not recover
a
spontaneous cardiac rhythm. Even after half an hour of this adapted
resuscitation the pressure of expired carbon gases [?] remained depressed.
We even applied several electric shocks during the reanimation to get
the
heart going.”
Prof Pavie:
“In the face of the ineffectiveness of the reanimation effort,
we decided
to stop all maneuvres after consultation with all of those taking part.
Death was declared at 0400.”